To guess about the past, use a modal + have been + -ing. The modal you choose shows how sure you are.
How sure are you? must → might/could/may → can't
must have been: you're sure it's true. Her boots were caked in mud. → She must have been walking in the fields.
might / could / may have been: it's only possible. He didn't pick up. → He might have been driving.
can't have been: you're sure it's NOT true. I saw her at her desk all afternoon. → She can't have been shopping in town.
Not "He didn't answer, so he must have been ignoring me.". Say "He didn't answer, so he might have been driving.". Don't jump to must (sure) when the evidence only makes something possible. Use might / could / may for a guess you're not certain about.
Try it: Maya: Diego's hands were white with chalk when he got home. Mateo: He ___ at Farrisen Gym. Choose the words for the blank. (must have been climbing / can't have been climbing / must have climbing) Answer: must have been climbing. Chalk on his hands points one way, so use must have been + -ing, not "can't have been".
Try it: Hiroshi: Was Wei at the movies last night? Camila: He ___ a movie. He was in my cooking class all evening. Choose the words for the blank. (can't have been watching / must have been watching / can't been watching) Answer: can't have been watching. Proof that something was impossible takes can't have been + -ing, keeping the have.
Use have been + the -ing form when you guess about an action that was in progress at that past moment, not a finished one.
Liam: The chair next to mine is still warm.
Ira: A student must have been sitting there a minute ago.
Not "A student must have been sit there a minute ago.". Say "A student must have been sitting there a minute ago.". After have been, use the -ing form.
Try it: Farid: Lars's hair was wet when he came in. Guess what Lars was doing. Leave out the tile you do not need. Answer: He must have been swimming. An action in progress takes have been + the -ing form, so "swim" is wrong.
Keep the have
In fast speech the have is hard to hear, but the full form always keeps it: modal + have + been + -ing.
Ira: Mei's laptop was still open on the table.
Liam: She might have been printing something downstairs.
Not "She might been printing something downstairs.". Say "She might have been printing something downstairs.". Keep the have: might have been, not "might been".
Try it: Amina: Yasmin's line was busy for an hour. Guess why. Leave out the tile you do not need. Answer: She might have been talking to a friend. The full form keeps the have: might have been talking, not "might been".
What are the common mistakes?
Incorrect
Correct
Why
He didn't answer, so he must have been ignoring me.
He didn't answer, so he might have been driving.
Don't jump to must (sure) when the evidence only makes something possible. Use might / could / may for a guess you're not certain about.
A student must have been sit there a minute ago.
A student must have been sitting there a minute ago.
After have been, use the -ing form.
She might been printing something downstairs.
She might have been printing something downstairs.