For a past cause with a result now, use if + had + the past participle, then would + the base verb.
A past cause with a result now
Mei: Do you ever miss swimming on a team?
Ethan: Sometimes. If I hadn't quit, I'd be much faster now.
Not "If I had studied harder, I would have been more confident now.". Say "If I had studied harder, I would be more confident now.". Now puts the result in the present: would + the base verb.
Try it: Wei: I never learned to drive, so I take the bus everywhere. Choose Ira's reply. (If you had learned, you would be more independent now. / If you had learned, you would have been more independent now.) Answer: If you had learned, you would be more independent now. The result is about now, so it takes would be, while "would have been" closes it in the past.
For a trait now with a past result, use if + the past form (were for be), then would have + the past participle.
Mei: If I were more patient, I'd have finished that guitar course.
Ethan: You still play every weekend, though.
Not "If she was braver, she would have applied.". Say "If she were braver, she would have applied.". In writing, use were for every person here. "Was" is casual speech.
Try it: Farid: Wei is so careful. He didn't sign up for the climbing trip last spring. Choose Ira's reply. (If he were less careful, he would have gone. / If he had been less careful, he would go.) Answer: If he were less careful, he would have gone. His carefulness is a trait now and the trip is past, so use were with would have gone.
Try it: Mateo: Diego is so patient. He waited an hour for us last week. Choose the reply in standard written English. (If he were less patient, he would have left. / If he was less patient, he would have left.) Answer: If he were less patient, he would have left. In unreal if-clauses, standard written English uses were for every person.
Which way does it run?
Find when the cause and the result happen: had with would runs from past to now, were with would have from now to past.
Mei: If the city had fixed the roads years ago, traffic wouldn't be this slow now.
Ethan: If it were less cautious, it would have fixed them.
Try it: Farid: I didn't book early, so the hotel is full now. Mei: I'm so disorganized. That's why I missed the concert ticket sale. Match each one. Which way does each run? Answer: Farid: I didn't book early, so the hotel is full now. → If I had booked early, I would have a room now. · Mei: I'm so disorganized. That's why I missed the concert ticket sale. → If I were more organized, I wouldn't have missed it. A past cause with a result now takes had with would, and a trait now takes were with would have.
What are the common mistakes?
Incorrect
Correct
Why
If I had studied harder, I would have been more confident now.
If I had studied harder, I would be more confident now.
Now puts the result in the present: would + the base verb.
If she was braver, she would have applied.
If she were braver, she would have applied.
In writing, use were for every person here. "Was" is casual speech.