Use should have + the past participle to say something was the right thing to do, but it didn't happen.
should have: the right thing you didn't do
Amina: We missed the start of the first film.
Ethan: I know. We should have left earlier.
Not "We should left earlier.". Say "We should have left earlier.". After should, add have + the past participle.
Try it: Lani: The cafe was full, and we didn't book. Reply to Lani. Leave out the word you do not need. Answer: We should have booked a table. For the right thing that didn't happen, use should have + the past participle: booked.
Use shouldn't have + the past participle when something was the wrong thing to do, and Should I have ...? to ask.
Amina: I ate all the popcorn before the film even started.
Ethan: You shouldn't have eaten it so fast! Should I have bought a bigger one?
Not "You shouldn't eaten it.". Say "You shouldn't have eaten it.". In the negative, keep have before the past participle.
Try it: Farid: Diego paid at the door, but the talk was free. Yasmin: Free? So Diego ___ paid. Choose the words for the blank. (shouldn't have / shouldn't / should have) Answer: shouldn't have. It was free, so paying was wrong: shouldn't have + the past participle.
It's have, never "of"
In should have, could have and would have, the word have often sounds like "of", but we always write have.
Amina: Sorry, I could have texted you first.
Ethan: It's fine. I should have saved you a seat.
Not "I could of called you.". Say "I could have called you.". Write have, even when it sounds like "of".
Try it: Mei: I carried all those boxes upstairs by myself. Diego: Why didn't you call me? I ___ helped you. Choose the words for the blank. (could have / could of / could had) Answer: could have. We always write have, though it sounds like "of": could have helped.
should have or could have?
Use should have to blame someone for not doing the right thing, and could have for a chance that was there but missed.
Ethan: There was free parking right outside. We could have driven.
Amina: And you should have told me before we took the bus!
Try it: Mateo: Was it wrong of me to leave early? Choose Liam's reply. (No, but you could have stayed longer. / No, but you should have stayed longer.) Answer: No, but you could have stayed longer. Leaving was not wrong, so it was only a missed chance: could have, while "should have" would blame him.
What are the common mistakes?
Incorrect
Correct
Why
We should left earlier.
We should have left earlier.
After should, add have + the past participle.
You shouldn't eaten it.
You shouldn't have eaten it.
In the negative, keep have before the past participle.
I could of called you.
I could have called you.
Write have, even when it sounds like "of".
Which is correct?
You should have went to bed earlier. / You should have gone to bed earlier. · Answer: You should have gone to bed earlier. · After should have, use the past participle: gone, not went.
I could have helped you. / I could of helped you. · Answer: I could have helped you. · It sounds like "of", but we always write have.
The talk was free, but Diego paid ten dollars. He should have paid. / The talk was free, but Diego paid ten dollars. He shouldn't have paid. · Answer: The talk was free, but Diego paid ten dollars. He shouldn't have paid. · Use shouldn't have for something that was a bad idea.