Questions sujet et objet : Who called? Who did you call? (A2)
La personne est au début de la réponse (My brother called me) ? Alors mets la forme du passé juste après Who, sans did.
Who called? (sans did)
My brother called me. → Who called you?
Not "Who did call you?" — say "Who called you?". My brother est au début de la réponse, donc il n’y a pas de did.
Essaie: Ira: ___ about the new rule? Amina: A teacher told me. We can't eat in class now. Choisis la question d’Ira. (Who did tell you / Who told you / Who did you tell) Réponse: Who told you — A teacher est au début de la réponse, donc la question n’a pas de did : Who told you?
Who did you call? (avec did)
La personne est après le verbe (I called my brother) ? Alors utilise did + le verbe à la forme de base : Who did you call?
I called my brother. → Who did you call?
Not "Who you called?" — say "Who did you call?". La réponse vient après le verbe (I called my brother), donc il te faut did.
Essaie: Ira: ___ at the concert? Amina: I saw a friend from my art class. Choisis la question d’Ira. (Who saw you / Who did you help / Who helped you / Who did you see) Réponse: Who did you see — C’est Amina qui a vu son amie, donc l’amie vient après le verbe, et la question prend did : Who did you see?
Demander ce qui s’est passé : What happened?
What happened? demande ce qui s’est passé. La forme du passé vient juste après What, sans did.
What happened on the bus?
Not "What did happen?" — say "What happened?". Pas de did dans What happened?
Essaie: Ira: ___? There's paper everywhere in the hall. Amina: A box fell off the table. Choisis la question d’Ira. (What happened / What did happen / Who called / Who did call) Réponse: What happened — What happened? n’a pas de did : le passé vient juste après What.
Où se trouve la réponse ?
Regarde la réponse. La personne est au début, avant le verbe ? Pose la question sans did. La personne est après le verbe ? Pose la question avec did.
The teacher helped me. → Who helped you?
I helped the teacher. → Who did you help?
Essaie: Amina: Somebody visited me last night. Ira: Really? ___? Choisis la question d’Ira. (Who did you call / Who called you / Who visited you / Who did you visit) Réponse: Who visited you — Quelqu’un a rendu visite à Amina, et Ira demande qui est cette personne, au début de la phrase : Who visited you? Pas de did.
Quelles sont les erreurs les plus fréquentes ?
Incorrect
Correct
Pourquoi
Who did call you?
Who called you?
My brother est au début de la réponse, donc il n’y a pas de did.
Who you called?
Who did you call?
La réponse vient après le verbe (I called my brother), donc il te faut did.