Knowing the answer, she raised her hand (C1 Grammar)

Updated October 9, 2026 · Haffenville team

Practice this now

When both halves share a subject, shrink the first half to an -ing phrase of reason or time; make it negative with Not.

Cut the opener to an -ing phrase

Practice this

When the first action finished first: Having + past participle

When the first action finished before the next, use Having + the past participle; a passive first action takes Having been + the past participle.

Make the -ing point at the main subject

The reader assumes the doer of the -ing is the main subject, so if they differ you get a dangling modifier.

What are the common mistakes?

IncorrectCorrectWhy
Because feeling tired, she left early.Feeling tired, she left early.With because, drop the joining word too: just Feeling, not "Because feeling".
Having arrive late, he apologized.Having arrived late, he apologized.After Having, use the past participle: arrived, not "arrive".
Watching from the window, the parade went past.Watching from the window, we saw the parade go past.The one doing the -ing must be the main subject. The parade was not watching; we were.