Use if + had + past participle, then would + base verb, when a past action still has a result now.
A past action with a result that still holds
Yasmin: You look tired today, Mateo.
Mateo: If I had gone to bed earlier, I would feel much better now.
Yasmin: If you hadn't stayed up so late, you wouldn't be this tired.
Not "If I had studied medicine, I would have been a doctor (right now).". Say "If I had studied medicine, I would be a doctor.". When the result is still true today, use would + base verb, not would have + past participle.
Try it: Mei: Can you play the guitar for us, Lars? Choose Lars's reply. (No, I never took lessons. If I had taken them, I would play well now. / No, I never took lessons. If I had taken them, I would have played well now.) Answer: No, I never took lessons. If I had taken them, I would play well now. The result is true now, so it takes would plus the base verb, while "would have played" closes it in the past.
Use if + were, then would have + past participle, when a lasting trait shaped a past event.
Yasmin: Why didn't you speak up at the meeting?
Mateo: If I were more confident, I would have said something.
Not "If I were calmer, I would wait. (about yesterday)". Say "If I were calmer, I would have waited.". The result is in the past, so it takes would have + past participle. (Was is also heard in the if-half, but were is the formal choice.)
Try it: Mateo: You plan everything so carefully. Did you join that last-minute trip to the coast in June? Choose Yasmin's reply. (No. If I were a spontaneous person, I would have gone. / No. If I were a spontaneous person, I would go.) Answer: No. If I were a spontaneous person, I would have gone. The trip was in June, so the result half needs would have plus the past participle: would have gone.
The formal version: drop "if" and invert
In formal English, drop if and put had or were before the subject; the meaning stays the same.
Yasmin: Is "Had she not left, she would be here now" correct?
Mateo: Yes, and for a lasting trait use were: Were he more careful, he would have checked.
Not "If had she accepted the offer, she would live here.". Say "Had she accepted the offer, she would live here.". Inversion replaces "if": move had (or were) in front of the subject and never keep both.
Try it: ____, he would be far more independent now. Build the formal version of the if-half "If he had learned to drive" without "if". Answer: Had he learned to drive. Dropping if puts had before the subject, followed by the past participle: Had he learned to drive.
Try it: Lani: I missed the early train, so I am still stuck at the station. Yasmin: I am naturally cautious, so I turned down a skydiving trip last year. Match each one. Which way does each run? Answer: Lani: I missed the early train, so I am still stuck at the station. → If I had caught the early train, I would be at the festival by now. · Yasmin: I am naturally cautious, so I turned down a skydiving trip last year. → If I were bolder, I would have gone skydiving. A past action with a present result takes had plus would, while a lasting trait with a past result takes were plus would have.
What are the common mistakes?
Incorrect
Correct
Why
If I had studied medicine, I would have been a doctor (right now).
If I had studied medicine, I would be a doctor.
When the result is still true today, use would + base verb, not would have + past participle.
If I were calmer, I would wait. (about yesterday)
If I were calmer, I would have waited.
The result is in the past, so it takes would have + past participle. (Was is also heard in the if-half, but were is the formal choice.)
If had she accepted the offer, she would live here.
Had she accepted the offer, she would live here.
Inversion replaces "if": move had (or were) in front of the subject and never keep both.