But for + a thing means "if it weren't for it": use it formally for what makes the difference, then would + the base verb.
But for + a thing: if it weren't for this
Ira: How did you finish the report so quickly, Hiroshi?
Hiroshi: But for Lani's notes, I would still be writing it.
Not "But for the notes, I will be stuck.". Say "But for the notes, I would be stuck.". The situation is imagined, so the result uses would, not "will".
Try it: Ira: Is the paper map helping on Senfarrow Brook Trail? Hiroshi: Very. But for the map, we ___ completely lost right now. Choose the words for the blank. (would be / will be / are) Answer: would be. But for points at an imagined situation, so the result takes would + the base verb: would be lost.
For a past result, use but for + a thing + would have + the past participle: it names what prevented something.
Ira: Why did you take the long way home last night?
Hiroshi: But for the roadworks, I would have taken the short one.
Not "But for the strike, the trains ran on time.". Say "But for the strike, the trains would have run on time.". The result did not happen, so use would have + the past participle.
Try it: Ira: Did you find the venue easily last night? Hiroshi: Yes. But for Lars's directions, we ___ the venue. Choose the words for the blank. (would have missed / would miss / missed) Answer: would have missed. An imagined result in the past takes would have + the past participle: would have missed.
But for + an -ing form: if it weren't for doing this
But for can take an -ing form, often with a possessive in front, to name an action: but for her reminding me.
Ira: Did you hand in the entry form on time?
Hiroshi: But for Lani's reminding me, I would have forgotten it completely.
Not "But for he stayed late, the shop would have closed.". Say "But for his staying late, the shop would have closed.". After but for, use a thing or an -ing form, never a full clause.
Try it: Ira: Did you get into the shared account by yourself? Hiroshi: Yes. ___ Choose the words for the blank. (But for knowing the password, I couldn't have logged in. / But for I knew the password, I couldn't have logged in. / But for know the password, I couldn't have logged in.) Answer: But for knowing the password, I couldn't have logged in. After but for, use a thing or an -ing form: but for knowing the password.
Try it: Ira: Did my charger help at the Metro station? Hiroshi: Yes. But for it, my phone ___ dead right now. Choose the words for the blank. (would be / would have been / is) Answer: would be. "Right now" fixes the imagined result in the present, so use would + the base verb: would be.
What are the common mistakes?
Incorrect
Correct
Why
But for the notes, I will be stuck.
But for the notes, I would be stuck.
The situation is imagined, so the result uses would, not "will".
But for the strike, the trains ran on time.
But for the strike, the trains would have run on time.
The result did not happen, so use would have + the past participle.
But for he stayed late, the shop would have closed.
But for his staying late, the shop would have closed.
After but for, use a thing or an -ing form, never a full clause.