In formal writing, cut which was or that were and keep the past participle when the action was done to the noun.
Drop "which was": leave the past participle
Sofia: Can you tighten "the proposal that was submitted on Monday"?
Amina: Yes: the proposal submitted on Monday.
Sofia: So "the figures which were collected in May" becomes the figures collected in May?
Not "the policy introducing last year". Say "the policy introduced last year". The policy is introduced by someone, so the action is done to it: keep the past participle introduced, not the -ing form.
Try it: the building which was restored after the fire Tighten it: cut "which was" and keep the past participle. (Leave out the word you don't need.) Answer: the building restored after the fire. Cutting "which was" leaves the past participle restored, which already carries the done-to meaning.
Cut who are or that is before an -ing form and keep the -ing form, because the noun itself does the action.
Sofia: How can I tighten "the members who are drafting the guidelines"?
Amina: Cut who are: the members drafting the guidelines.
Not "People lived near the airport complained about the noise.". Say "People living near the airport complained about the noise.". The people are doing the living, so keep the -ing form living. Live takes no object here, so lived cannot follow the noun.
Try it: researchers who are studying the climate Tighten it: cut "who are" and keep the -ing form. (Leave out the word you don't need.) Answer: researchers studying the climate. Cutting "who are" leaves the -ing form studying, which carries the active meaning by itself.
Move it in front: join with a hyphen
To make a noun phrase denser, move a phrase in front of the noun as one hyphenated piece, with measurement words singular.
Amina: Can "a report of 40 pages" go in front of the noun?
Sofia: Yes, write a 40-page report, and "a plan for the short term" becomes a short-term plan.
Not "a five hour meeting". Say "a five-hour meeting". In front of the noun the words act as one, so join them with a hyphen: five-hour.
Try it: a training protocol based on evidence Move the phrase in front of the noun as one hyphenated piece. (Leave out the word you don't need.) Answer: an evidence-based training protocol. In front of the noun, "based on evidence" becomes the hyphenated evidence-based: an evidence-based training protocol.
Try it: Sofia: When will the group going through the applications meet? Choose Amina's reply. (The committee reviewing the applications will meet at noon. / The committee reviewed the applications will meet at noon.) Answer: The committee reviewing the applications will meet at noon. The committee does the reviewing, so the -ing form fits, while the past participle would mean the committee was reviewed.
What are the common mistakes?
Incorrect
Correct
Why
the policy introducing last year
the policy introduced last year
The policy is introduced by someone, so the action is done to it: keep the past participle introduced, not the -ing form.
People lived near the airport complained about the noise.
People living near the airport complained about the noise.
The people are doing the living, so keep the -ing form living. Live takes no object here, so lived cannot follow the noun.
a five hour meeting
a five-hour meeting
In front of the noun the words act as one, so join them with a hyphen: five-hour.