When two ideas share the same person, start with the -ing form to mean because or while; it sounds formal and written.
Start with the -ing form
Lars: While I waited for the bus, I read the notes.
Ira: In writing, make it shorter: 'Waiting for the bus, I read the notes.'
Not "Walking home, the rain started.". Say "Walking home, I got caught in the rain.". The -ing part belongs to the person in the main idea, so name that person next.
Try it: Mei: Because I felt nervous, I said nothing. Make Mei's sentence shorter, starting with the -ing form. Leave out the tile you do not need. Answer: Feeling nervous, I said nothing. The -ing form replaces "Because I felt", and the same person follows the comma.
When the idea is passive (something was done to the person or thing), start with the past participle to mean because or which was.
Ira: The poster which was designed by Maya is in the hall.
Lars: Shorter: 'The poster designed by Maya is in the hall.'
Not "The cake baking by Camila was delicious.". Say "The cake baked by Camila was delicious.". For a passive idea, use the past participle (baked), not the -ing form.
Try it: Ira: The bridge, which was damaged in the storm, is now closed. Make Ira's sentence shorter, starting with the past participle. Leave out the tile you do not need. Answer: Damaged in the storm, the bridge is now closed. A passive idea starts with the past participle, so "Damaging" is wrong.
Start with having + the past participle
When one action finishes before the next starts, begin with having + the past participle to mean after or because.
Ira: After I had read all the entries, I made my choice.
Lars: Formal version: 'Having read all the entries, I made my choice.'
Not "Spending all my money, I couldn't buy a ticket.". Say "Having spent all my money, I couldn't buy a ticket.". Plain -ing does not show which action came first; having + past participle means earlier and already finished.
Try it: Lars: After we had eaten, we left the cafe. Make Lars's sentence shorter, starting with having + the past participle. Leave out the tile you do not need. Answer: Having eaten, we left the cafe. Having + the past participle marks the earlier, finished action, so "Eating" is wrong.
What are the common mistakes?
Incorrect
Correct
Why
Walking home, the rain started.
Walking home, I got caught in the rain.
The -ing part belongs to the person in the main idea, so name that person next.
The cake baking by Camila was delicious.
The cake baked by Camila was delicious.
For a passive idea, use the past participle (baked), not the -ing form.
Spending all my money, I couldn't buy a ticket.
Having spent all my money, I couldn't buy a ticket.
Plain -ing does not show which action came first; having + past participle means earlier and already finished.